The most widely read magazine for Canadian lawyers
Issue link: https://digital.canadianlawyermag.com/i/1544922
20 www.canadianlawyermag.com TOP PERSONAL INJURY BOUTIQUES 2026 to adhere to them. Trial dates are also set, where appropriate, to maintain pressure on defendants to either negotiate or litigate to resolution. In Ontario and other regions, practitioners report similar delays, noting that it is no longer something that can be managed away. Brenda Hollingsworth, co-founding partner at Auger Hollingsworth Accident & Injury Lawyers, says trial timelines now regu- larly extend beyond five years, even with an aggressive approach to moving cases forward. Her firm has responded by building cases earlier to create leverage before trial becomes a realistic outcome. "We've been front-end loading the evidence on our case for about five years now to increase opportunities for timely but also generous resolution," she says. Clients are more informed and expect greater involvement AI has fundamentally changed how clients approach legal representation, with firms reporting that clients are arriving with sophisticated questions that demand technical answers delivered in a comprehen- sible fashion. Legal industry research shows a growing number of clients using online and AI- assisted tools to research claims before seeking counsel, raising expectations around responsiveness, transparency, and the level of explanation provided. "We are intentional and transparent in our communications, making sure clients feel like active participants in their own case, rather than passengers in processes they do not understand," says Weir Bowen LLP partner Cynthia Carels. Firms are also placing greater emphasis on trauma-informed approaches, recognizing that the emotional complexity of cases has never been more front of mind. Anatomy of a personal injury case Several of Canada's Best Personal Injury Law Firms of 2026 share their approach to a case from intake to resolution, and what separates strong outcomes and average ones. Weir Bowen LLP Trial capability and depth in complex personal injury litigation define this practice, particularly in medical malpractice. Feedback highlights a firm prepared to take on difficult matters and carry them through, supported by experienced lawyers and a team- based approach. What CL voters said: • "Weir Bowen LLP has a reputation in the industry of not shying away from difficult cases, and also having many important, precedent-setting wins at trial." How early case selection and expert framing drive outcomes Intake and early case assessment Weir Bowen treats intake as a dual test of viability and outcome. "At intake, we are asking two questions simultaneously: is there a case here, and can we win it? Those are not always the same thing," says Carels. The team looks beyond records to assess the full context of the claim, including the individual at its centre. It also tests the case from both sides, anticipating how the defence is likely to respond. Building the case Medical evidence is treated as foundational, with work beginning early and built around expert input that can withstand challenge. "The medical evidence has to do two things: establish that something went wrong and establish that the wrong- doing actually caused the bad outcome," adds Carels. Expert selection is approached with equal care, with a focus on specialists who can explain complex issues under cross-examination. " T he right exper t does not just suppor t the case; the y shape how the entire narrative is understood." Negotiation and resolution Negotiation is treated as an extension of preparation. Files are built with trial in mind, and that readiness shapes how reso- lution is approached. By the time discus- sions begin, proceeding to trial remains a live option. The outcome is driven by the strength of the case rather than tactics at the table. Howie, Sacks & Henry LLP Complex, high-value personal injur y matters are a core focus, handled through a disciplined litigation approach. Feedback points to a team that c o m b i n e s t e c h n i c a l s t r e n g t h w i t h c o n s i s t e n t c l i e n t c o m m u n i c a t i o n and credibility across both sides of the bar. What CL voters said: • "They stand out because they're built for serious, high-stakes injury litigation, not high-volume, quick-settlement files." "We negotiate from preparation, not from hope. By the time we're at the table, our case has been built as though trial is the next step" Cynthia Carels, Weir Bowen LLP SPECIAL REPORT