Canadian Lawyer - sample

50 M A Y 2 0 1 7 w w w . C A N A D I A N L a w y e r m a g . c o m The chosen alternatives Demand for alternative dispute resolution growing in wake of Jordan By Mallory Hendry A ccording to the lawyers at the arbitration chambers on the top 10 list who spoke to Canadian Lawyer, we're on the cusp of an alternative dispute reso- lution revolution. "People are about to realize they have to be a lot more creative," says Allan Stitt, owner of ADR Chambers. "I don't mean inside the box but a lot more creative." He says he's heard about chess clock arbitrations, Redfern schedules and how discovery is moving from where you just discover anything that could possibly be relevant, and while he calls these interest- ing developments, he still feels they are operating within the box and failing 98 per cent of the market. He says the vast major- ity of disputes don't justify a full-blown arbitration process and there is an oppor- tunity now for the arbitration community to start coming up with ways people can do arbitration in an expedited way. "I think what's going to happen next is some lawyers are going to really try to be creative and other lawyers will have to be brought along kicking and screaming to say proportionality is going to have to become more important than due process in arbitration — and that's for me the crucial thing," Stitt says. "Once people take that step, then all bets are off. Anything goes." Stitt says he's developed expedited rules and seen others try to use similar ones only to meet resistance. ADR Chambers has done a few cases using Stitt's rules and they've gone well, he says, but you need "really forward-thinking" lawyers on both sides. More often than not, one of them says no, but despite some pushback, he is sure this is where arbitration is headed. Brian Casey, of Bay Street Chambers, agrees that arbitrators have to find ways to be creative in their delivery, but he warns that they also must be careful not to become slaves to a rigid procedure. "We got into arbitration in part to avoid the sometimes overly rigorous rules of court and one thing you don't want to see is arbitrators simply developing a new set of rules that they think must be followed," he says. "Flexibility is key." For Paul Torrie, president of Global Resolutions, the fact it's a non-regulated profession means for mediators to con- tinue to be value added to the process, they need to "up their game on their creativity" through their effectiveness, energy and perseverance. In line with Stitt, Torrie thinks that, going back to evolutionary process, "we reached one plateau of development and are about to launch into another." He adds the Supreme Court of Canada's decision in R. v. Jordan has had the effect of essentially prioritizing criminal cases, which consequently pushes civil cases fur- ther down on the priority list. "This means mediation becomes even more relevant and important," he says. "In the last few years, there's been a greater number of people offering mediation ser- vices and as a consequence I think there are a lot more options for counsel and their clients. I think that's very healthy and good for everybody." Paul Iacono, founder of YorkStreet Dispute Resolution Group Inc., says all of the problems in the area of civil justice that created the need for ADR in the first place are still there — if anything, they're getting worse. Civil justice and ADR will always be joined at the hip, he says. "What's happening now is maybe one per cent of all of the civil actions that are launched are actually getting to trial," Iaco- no says. "When they get to the courthouse, they take too long. So there will always be a need for ADR." Casey agrees the demand for ADR is still high, adding the cases he deals with most vary year to year, though he's found it evenly divided between domestic and international work lately, with "a lot of work in the energy field in arbitration." While the biggest area is still insurance and personal injury, this historical leader is losing some of its dominance, says Iacono. "That business is shrinking because there's going to be fewer lawsuits, the threshold's higher, the deductible's higher," he says. "I think, eventually, in the area of accident benefits, that's probably going to turn into something like workers compen- sation." Torrie agrees the majority of work Global Resolutions does has a negligence base to it, and he says that, for his firm, the second largest group after that is commer- cial matters. The area of estates mediation is a rap- idly growing area. These cases are more traditional mediation, Iacono says, noting it's becoming a huge source of litigation as "billions of dollars pass from one genera- tion to the next and there is inevitably arguments," usually about money. They are straightforward disputes, he says. One area that's challenging YorkStreet right now is work with First Nations, which Iacono says is groundbreaking. "It requires what I call a 'hybrid form' of mediation," he says. "It really is a team approach because in these kinds of dis- putes there are so many moving parts.

• Cover