w w w . c a n a d i a n l a w y e r m a g . c o m N O V E M B E R / D E C E M B E R 2 0 1 8 3
I
n this issue, we profiled Supreme Court Chief Justice Richard Wagner in our regular
"Cross Examined" section of the magazine. While we profile lawyers and judges in every
issue, this time we felt it required a bit more space, given our subject.
Despite the name of the section, we don't generally cross-examine the lawyers and
judges who we profile. We prefer to hear about their career and accomplishments in a less
confrontational manner. For Wagner's profile, Elizabeth Raymer spoke with the chief justice,
but she also heard from many of his colleagues throughout his career, his son and former
Supreme Court judges.
One of the common themes Raymer heard from many was transparency. Wagner has
already brought several initiatives forward to improve openness at the Supreme Court and, as
Raymer found, this has been a consistent preoccupation throughout his career.
While these initiatives are laudable, it was one remark he made that sparked my interest
— that he anticipates turning his attention to the reform of judicial conduct matters as well.
The SCC has already made improvements under Wagner, but the same cannot be said for the
Canadian Judicial Council, which is chaired by the chief justice.
Recent examples that have hit the headlines demonstrate how transparency is desperately
needed. For example, the treatment of Justice Patrick Smith, who temporarily took over the
role of dean at the Bora Laskin Faculty of Law after former dean Angelique EagleWoman
resigned citing "systemic discrimination," has been mystifying. Even though Heather Smith,
chief justice of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice, had approved the temporary appoint-
ment after receiving a legal opinion, the CJC chose to launch an inquiry.
Further back, many critics, including a former Supreme Court judge and law school dean,
found the CJC's allegations against Lori Douglas — thoroughly dissected in a cover story in
our pages in 2016 — were "badly handled" and "unsavoury and unnecessary."
The CJC has also recently asserted that its decisions are immune from judicial review.
While there are different ways to improve transparency, arguing that judges who are being
investigated should not have access to court review seems problematic.
The Supreme Court of Canada is not perfect, and it can still suffer criticism from the
public when it seems distant or out of touch. But it has steadily increased its transparency
over the years, with video cameras in the court, facta available on its website and chief justices
such as Beverley McLachlin speaking publicly about the court and how it works.
Richard Wagner is carrying on this tradition and bringing his own flavour to the court.
Transparency is clearly as important to him now as it has been throughout his career. While
he is not the only person who can improve the transparency of the Canadian Judicial Coun-
cil, I hope his zeal for transparency is applied there as it has been on our top court.
E D I T O R ' S D E S K
OPENING THE CANADIAN
JUDICIAL COUNCIL
By Tim Wilbur
Director/Group Publisher: Karen Lorimer
karen.lorimer@tr.com
Managing Editor: Tim Wilbur
tim.wilbur@tr.com
Acting Associate Editor: Aidan Macnab
aidan.macnab@tr.com
Copy Editor: Patricia Cancilla
Art Director: Bill Hunter
Production Co-ordinator: Catherine Giles
catherine.giles@tr.com
Contributors: Michael McKiernan,
Jean Sorensen, donalee Moulton, Mark Cardwell,
Geoff Ellwand, Marg. Bruineman, Elizabeth Raymer,
Anita Balakrishnan
Canadian Lawyer is published 10 times a year by Thomson Reuters Canada Ltd.
All rights reserved. Contents may not be reprinted without written
permission. The opinions expressed in articles are not necessarily those
of the publisher. Information presented is compiled from sources believed to
be accurate, however, the publisher assumes no responsibility for errors or
omissions.
Canadian Lawyer disclaims any warranty as to the accuracy, completeness or
currency of the contents of this publication and disclaims all liability in respect
of the results of any action taken or not taken in reliance upon information in
this publication.
Sales and Business Development
Sales Manager:
Paul Burton
E-mail: paul.burton@tr.com
Tel: 416-649-9928
Consultant, Strategy and Business Development:
Ivan Ivanovitch
E-mail: ivan.ivanovitch@tr.com
Tel: 416-887-4300
Business Development Consultant:
Kimberlee Pascoe
E-mail: kimberlee.pascoe@tr.com
Tel: 416-996-1739
Account Executive:
Steffanie Munroe
E-mail: steffanie.munroe@tr.com
Tel: 416-315-5879
Canadian Lawyer
Thomson Reuters Canada Ltd.
One Corporate Plaza, 2075 Kennedy Rd.,
Toronto, ON. M1T 3V4
Tel: (416) 298-5141 Fax: (416) 649-7870
E-mail: cl.editor@tr.com
Web: canadianlawyermag.com
Linkedin: linkedin.com/groups/4917423
Twitter: @canlawmag
Facebook: facebook.com/CanLawMag
Publications Mail Agreement
#40766500
ISSN 0703-2129 © 2018
HST Registration #R121349799
RETURN UNDELIVERABLE CANADIAN ADDRESS TO: CIRCULATION DEPARTMENT
One Corporate Plaza 2075 Kennedy RD., Toronto, ON. M1T 3V4
RETOURNER TOUTE CORRESPONDANCE NE POUVANT ÊTRE LIVRÉE AU CANADA
AU SERVICE DES PUBLICATIONS
One Corporate Plaza, 2075 Kennedy Rd., Toronto, ON. M1T 3V4
Circulation/Address Changes/
Subscriptions
Keith Fulford
Tel: (416) 649-9585
Fax: (416) 649-7870
E-mail: keith.fulford@tr.com
Subscription rates: Canada1 year print and digital $102 plus HST,
1 year digital only $99. Outside Canada 1 year print & digital $99 USD,
1 year digital only $99.
For all circulation inquiries and address changes send a copy of your mailing label
or labels along with your request in writing to Canadian Lawyer,
One Corporate Plaza, 2075 Kennedy Rd., Toronto, ON. M1T 3V4
@canlawmag
tim.wilbur@tr.com
Corrections
In our October issue's Forensic and Criminal Law report, "Fallible evidence," some comments
about portable police lab and black box technology made by Kathy Gruspier were mistakenly
attributed to Caitlin Pakosh. In our Manitoba Regional Wrap in the same issue, we said Donald
Douglas is the managing partner and CEO of Thompson Dorfman Sweatman, when in fact
Keith LaBossiere is currently in that role. Canadian Lawyer apologizes for the errors.
